NSU Ethics Bowl: A Platform for Ethical Reasoning and Leadership Development

NSU Ethics Bowl: A Platform for Ethical Reasoning and Leadership Development

The NSU Ethics Bowl offers students a unique opportunity to engage in meaningful, structured discussions about complex ethical dilemmas. Unlike traditional debates, the Ethics Bowl focuses on ethical reasoning, critical thinking, and respectful dialogue, rather than simply "winning" an argument. Participants are judged on their ability to analyze ethical issues, communicate effectively, and respond insightfully to opposing viewpoints. For more details, visit the Association for Practical and Professional Ethics website at https://www.appe-ethics.org/. 

The topics discussed in the Ethics Bowl often reflect real-world challenges, including business ethics, medical decisions, environmental policies, artificial intelligence, and social justice. Examples of past dilemmas include balancing privacy with security, addressing corporate social responsibility, and considering the ethical implications of emerging technologies.

Participation in the Ethics Bowl is open to all NSU students, regardless of major or prior experience. Students need only a willingness to learn and engage in meaningful conversations. By participating, students develop critical skills in ethical reasoning, teamwork, and public speaking. These abilities are highly sought after in professional settings and enhance resumes by showcasing leadership and analytical capabilities. Networking opportunities with peers, faculty, and industry professionals further enrich the experience.

Teams consist of 4-6 students and are formed based on interest and availability. Weekly team meetings allow participants to analyze case studies, practice presentations, and receive guidance from faculty mentors like Dr. Megan Weinkauf. "Seeing students grow in their ability to think critically and articulate their ethical reasoning is incredibly rewarding," Dr. Weinkauf shared. "The Ethics Bowl is about equipping students with skills that extend far beyond the competition—it’s about preparing them to navigate the ethical challenges they’ll face in their careers and communities."

Competitions take place annually, with state and regional events in the fall and nationals in the spring. This year, the state competition will be held in Oklahoma City at the end of October, and regionals will occur in early November in San Antonio, Texas. Both events are hosted on weekends, and travel expenses are covered for participants.

NSU Ethics Bowl teams have a strong tradition of excellence, with students frequently earning recognition for their preparation and ethical reasoning. A standout moment came this year when team leaders Jacob Hardbarger and Lauren Shores skillfully tackled a challenging case on Non-Disclosure Agreements. Their exceptional analysis secured a win for NSU in that round, highlighting the power of preparation and teamwork.

Jacob Hardbarger, a two-year Ethics Bowl participant, shared, "Debate has guided me to find my voice. Ethics Bowl has taught me how to use my voice in support of things that matter to me most. Thanks to CBT and its stellar support of NSU Ethics Bowl, I will soon graduate and be sent forth into the world advocating for others and ensuring my communities are well informed, safe, and make excellent ethical decisions through both public policy and business practices."

Lauren Shores echoed Jacob’s sentiments, saying, "I'd like to add that our coach, Megan Weinkauf, was a guiding force in our success this year! I learned a lot from the competitions, my teammates and competitors, and Dr. Weinkauf—it was a valuable experience for me. Jacob and I were also able to connect as a two-person team, and I think that connection aided in our reasonings and accomplishments this semester. My favorite moment was probably at regionals. At that point, I found myself really immersed in the argument. I had a lot to say, and having the evidence to back up the way I viewed the issue at hand was refreshing."

Students interested in joining the Ethics Bowl can contact Dr. Megan Weinkauf at weinkauf@nsuok.edu. Announcements about team recruitment are made at the start of each semester, with deadlines for team formation and initial meetings occurring early in the term. The Ethics Bowl provides students with an unparalleled opportunity to grow as leaders, thinkers, and ethical decision-makers. For those considering joining, this is your chance to make a difference and engage with some of the most important issues of our time.

Dr. Weinkauf’s dedication to the Ethics Bowl and her guidance as a mentor have been instrumental in fostering an environment where students can thrive. Her expertise and encouragement help ensure the program's continued success and impact at NSU.